Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra
Great news for readers of Nietzsche and comparative philosophy:
Santiago E. Maneiro has just published (open access) his excellent doctoral thesis “Buddhism in Nietzsche’s Philosophy” (UNS, 2026). This is the most rigorous study available of Buddhism’s semantic role in Nietzsche’s work—as both a critical cultural metaphor and a religious tool against Christianity and European nihilism.
My Spanish isn’t great so it’s a bit laborious for me to access, but the material is so good I kept working through it. I was delighted to discover that Maneiro was inspired by, and draws heavily from, my book “Hegel’s India: A Reinterpretation, with Texts” to contextualize the German reception of Indian thought. scholar.google.com/scholar_url?ur…
https://x.com/ASR_Metta/status/2115330438499553659?a=ZiRBkHgIvudEVMGoCmA&s=19
Yes, Sita Ram Goel, Arun Shourie, and V.S. Naipaul are frequently accused by leftist and secular critics of reinforcing a narrative of Hindu victimhood, though their intellectual frameworks and motivations differ considerably. [1, 2, 3]
To understand why they face this accusation, it helps to examine how critics view their work alongside how their supporters interpret it.
The Case for the Accusation (The Critics' Perspective)
Critics argue that these writers constructed a historical grievance narrative that portrays Hindus as perpetual, passive victims of foreign aggression, laying the psychological groundwork for modern right-wing political mobilization.
- Sita Ram Goel: As a pioneer of the indigenous "Voice of India" school of thought, Goel spent decades documenting Islamic iconoclasm. In works like Hindu Temples: What Happened to Them, he compiled extensive evidence of temple destructions. Critics argue that by framing centuries of complex, political medieval history purely through the lens of religious trauma and unavenged civilizational humiliation, he institutionalized a psychological sense of victimhood. [2]
- Arun Shourie: A fierce polemicist and former journalist, Shourie attacked institutions he believed were biased against Hindu heritage. In Eminent Historians, he accused Marxist academics of systematically erasing the history of Hindu suffering under Islamic rulers to maintain secular harmony. Critics charge that his books—including those targeting Christian missionary conversions (Harvesting Our Souls)—foster a defensive siege mentality among a religious majority. [2, 4]
- V.S. Naipaul: The Nobel laureate observed India from the detached perspective of the diaspora. In his famous trilogy, particularly India: A Wounded Civilization, he argued that centuries of foreign conquests had intellectually crippled the Hindu mind, creating a culture of retreat and worldly defeat. Critics accuse Naipaul of romanticizing the pre-Islamic past and providing intellectual validation for aggrieved Hindu nationalism when he famously described the destruction of the Vijayanagara Empire or the Babri Masjid demolition as a valid, seismic awakening of long-suppressed historical emotions. [1, 3]
The Counter-Perspective (The Authors' Framework)
Supporters and the authors themselves reject the term "victimhood," arguing instead that their work is an exercise in civilizational truth-telling and psychological decolonization. [1, 3]
- Breaking a Taboo: From their viewpoint, post-independence Indian academia practiced a form of historical negationism that actively suppressed the trauma of foreign invasions. They argue they were merely filling a vacuum by restoring facts to the historical record.
- Agency vs. Victimhood: Rather than encouraging Hindus to feel helpless, their goal was to awaken political agency and cultural pride. Naipaul argued that recognizing the "wounds" of the past was the only way for India to build a modern, self-aware identity, rather than remaining trapped in historical self-deception. [1]
| Author | Primary Focus | Critical Accusation | Ideological Defense |
|---|---|---|---|
| Sita Ram Goel | Medieval iconoclasm and temple destruction | Fixating on past trauma to breed modern resentment. | Documenting historical truths suppressed by institutional bias. |
| Arun Shourie | Academic bias and institutional challenges to Hinduism | Generating a majoritarian siege mentality. | Exposing ideological double standards in secular Indian discourse. |
| V.S. Naipaul | Civilizational psychology and the trauma of colonization | Providing literary cover for historical grievances. | Encouraging essential self-analysis to overcome cultural decay. |
If you want to explore this dynamic further, let me know if you would like to:
- Look into specific historical disputes analyzed by these authors (like the Ayodhya debate).
- Examine the Marxist or secular historians' rebuttal to Arun Shourie's Eminent Historians.
- Trace how V.S. Naipaul’s view of India evolved over his career.
- GoogleAI
A mother's brain is rewired - The growing love of a baby for their mother is a beautiful, biologically driven process rooted in survival, comfort, and emotional synchronization. From...
Sachidanand Mohanty wrote about women writers of Odisha - Collated by Tusar Nath Mohapatra Of all my contemporary academics, Sachi was the most authentic Sri Aurobindo scholar, especially with reference to Sri ...
Virginia Woolf, Naomi Wolf, Mary Douglas, and Foucault - The shift in how certain rituals are perceived—moving from deeply sacred, symbolic acts to being viewed by some as "gross" or archaic—is a well-document...
[PDF] Spiritual Tourism: A Grounded Theory Approach
M Sudiarta, IW Bratayasa, IN Subadra - Bali Journal of Hospitality, Tourism and …, 2025
Spiritual tourism is a rapid growing segment of the travel industry that focuses on
journeys aiming at fostering personal growth, self-discovery, and connection with
sacred or transcendent experiences. This article explores the evolution, current …
journeys aiming at fostering personal growth, self-discovery, and connection with
sacred or transcendent experiences. This article explores the evolution, current …
[PDF] Assessing the Influence of OBCs in the Politics of Madhya Pradesh: A Holistic Perspective
N Payasi - MPJSS
… He feels that OBCs have found their aspirations fulfilled under the umbrella of
Hindutva. He argues that the role of OBCs is pivotal in having any form of coalition to
challenge the hegemony of the BJP RSS and this symbolises the central importance …
Hindutva. He argues that the role of OBCs is pivotal in having any form of coalition to
challenge the hegemony of the BJP RSS and this symbolises the central importance …
[PDF] Towards a Multispecies Approach to Caste in Sinhala Society: Interspecies Dynamics between Cinnamon and the Salagama People
KT Silva - CASTE/A Global Journal on Social Exclusion, 2025
This article deploys a multispecies perspective to understand the role of human and
non-human actors shaping the Sinhala caste system in Sri Lanka. Apart from human
interlocutors, certain animal species (eg elephants, cattle and fish) and certain plant …
non-human actors shaping the Sinhala caste system in Sri Lanka. Apart from human
interlocutors, certain animal species (eg elephants, cattle and fish) and certain plant …
Legacy of the Great Divide of 1947: Environmental Cost, Migrations, and Other Impacts
GM Rahman - Handbook of Migration, International Relations and …, 2025
Indian Independence Act of 1947 divided the British Empire in India into two
dominions: India and Pakistan. Colonial Bengal, a province of British India, was
partitioned for the second time in 1947. Hindu majority West Bengal remained in the …
dominions: India and Pakistan. Colonial Bengal, a province of British India, was
partitioned for the second time in 1947. Hindu majority West Bengal remained in the …
[PDF] Political Parties in Culture: Dynamics, Allegiances and Socio-Cultural Issues-An Ethnographic Study in North Dumdum of Kolkata, West Bengal, India
S Chakraborty, A Das, N Dhar - Antrocom Online Journal of Anthropology, 2025
This study explores the socio-political dynamics of major political parties in North
Dum Dum Municipality (NDDM), West Bengal. The focus of this study is on the
supporters of these parties, the party systems, the political symbolism of these parties …
Dum Dum Municipality (NDDM), West Bengal. The focus of this study is on the
supporters of these parties, the party systems, the political symbolism of these parties …
Escaping the DVD dispositif: John Abraham and the historical exhibition
P Patra - South Asian History and Culture, 2025
Delving into the many aesthetic, political and production conditions that surround
and occupy John Abraham’s radical epistolary film Amma Ariyan (1986), this article
places the disappearances of the activists and figures, in and outside the screen, in …
and occupy John Abraham’s radical epistolary film Amma Ariyan (1986), this article
places the disappearances of the activists and figures, in and outside the screen, in …
India's political shift in a Latin American mirror: the dialectics of dependency and monopoly capital
RA Sirohi - Review of International Political Economy, 2025
The last decade or two has witnessed a surge of right-wing, authoritarian
movements across the world. India, despite its long history of liberal democracy, has
not been an exception to this trend. With the scale and nature of the transformations …
movements across the world. India, despite its long history of liberal democracy, has
not been an exception to this trend. With the scale and nature of the transformations …
[PDF] A Tale of Two Cities: A Study in Community and Sociopolitical Relations for the South Asian Diaspora in Lyon and Paris
S Parampottil - 2025
This thesis studies the South Asian diaspora in France, focused on the cities of Paris
and Lyon. The relatively small communities of South Asian immigrants and their
descendants in each city navigate French society at a time when immigration is one …
and Lyon. The relatively small communities of South Asian immigrants and their
descendants in each city navigate French society at a time when immigration is one …
[PDF] People's Conceptualization of Government, Governance and Legitimacy: Some Reflections Based on Urban India
SM Channa - Journal of Urban Ethnography ̶ ̶ ̶ ̶ ̶ ̶ ̶ ̶ ̶ ̶ ̶ …, 2025
Cities are known for their internal heterogeneity and differences, usually mapped out
on the city’s geographical pattern. Who gets to live where and what kind of
resources are available to people living in the different spatial locations is largely …
on the city’s geographical pattern. Who gets to live where and what kind of
resources are available to people living in the different spatial locations is largely …
[HTML] What Caused Rwanda's Genocide?
M Nasir
Memoona Nasir delves into the Hutu-Tutsi conflict that culminated in Rwanda’s
devastating 1994 genocide. In her analysis of the complex relationship between
identity and conflict, she unveils how ethnicity has been a catalyst instead of the …
devastating 1994 genocide. In her analysis of the complex relationship between
identity and conflict, she unveils how ethnicity has been a catalyst instead of the …
No comments:
Post a Comment